Computer software can be described as an information system that is designed like a framework. This is geared towards making the process of commands efficient and simple. With the progress in technology and the rise in the use of computers across the world, software development methodologies have moved from an attitude of code & fix to modern methods that have made planning as well as discipline a routine. There are quite a few software development methods in use today and let us look at each briefly with the advantages and disadvantages. The methodologies, discussed below, are not presented in any particular order.
1. Big Bang Model
This model does not follow any trend in software development and this is usually implemented when the client is not aware himself of what his requirements are or how they should shape up. The Big Bang Model is used for smaller projects. This is a very simple model and no formal procedures are employed in the development process.
Advantages of Big Bang Model –
- The model is an extremely simple one.
- There is very little pre-planning that is required and at times the development commences without any planning.
- The resources required are very few.
- It is very easy to manage.
- Using this model gives adequate exposure to beginners looking to develop their skills.
Disadvantages of Big Bang Model –
- This is a high risk model and this is why it is not recommended for complex and large projects.
- If the client’s requirements are not understood then the project faces the risk of being scrapped and restarted.
2. Prototype Model
Software development means that there are processes involved in the creation of a program until its release and maintenance stages. Understanding the requirements of the software and conducting relevant market research aid in the creation of a prototype of the software. This prototype then undergoes a development process. This kind of software development process allows developers to create a prototype of the solution that they visualize so that the clients can see how it will run. Any modification can be added before the actual software is developed. A typical prototype methodology flows in the following way – the requirements create a prototype/design concept and is shown to the client for an evaluation and review, then the updates and changes if any are addressed before the actual development process and test phases and finally the maintenance stage is reached. As an example Structural engineers can, with the assistance of prototypes, create a new design and then conduct tests on it to understand the design’s resilience to vibration, noise etc. A prototype model can help to catch problems that one cannot avoid in a waterfall type model.
Advantages of Prototype Model –
- Clients find it easier to understand the design of the software with a prototype model. The way the software will ultimately function is better felt with this methodology.
- The development experts who are working on the prototype can also gauge if the software is able to match up to the client’s expectations and make changes accordingly.
- Risk factors are easily identified very early on and steps to correct these errors are also possible with the prototype model.
- Another benefit is that the designers are able to get important feedback earlier in the development cycle from testers. This saves on unnecessary expenses post launch.
- Real time tests and constant interaction between the client and the developer helps to forge a positive relationship between the two.
Disadvantages of Prototype Model –
- It is the developing agency that bears the cost of the prototype model so costing must be considered at every stage to reduce waste of resources.
- Not every software developer likes constant changes that a client can insist on.
- Repeated changes and risk analysis that cause too many design changes can be detrimental to the workflow process and can be very distracting.
3. Waterfall Model
This model is traditional and is also used commonly. It is also referred to as the traditional / conventional approach and is more of a classical form of the process of software development. The Waterfall model uses an approach that has 5 sequential and important stages. These stages include Client requirement gathering, Design sampling, Implementation, Testing and finally Maintenance. The linear sequential flow in the Waterfall model means that the next stage in the development process commences only if the previous stage/process is completed and definitely involves detailed documentation and verification of all the requirements. There is no set method to return to the earlier phase in case there are changes in the requirements. This model is also known as a heavyweight methodology as the processes are long and are quite inflexible. Waterfall Model is not very accepting of change but it does have some unique features as listed below.
Advantages of Waterfall Model –
- Waterfall model can be implemented for projects of all sizes.
- Testing is an inherent part of every stage of this model.
- This kind of software development offers a clear and concrete approach.
- Documentation for every stage is maintained by the developers making it easy to map trails.
- This model of software development is simple and easy to work with making it a popular choice among amateur developers.
- This is a rigid model yet this works in its favor as it is this rigidity that makes it that much easier to manage. Smaller projects benefit from the Waterfall model as the requirements are easier to understand.
- The Waterfall Model ensures that the processes are completed in stages and this is a time saving factor.
Disadvantages of Waterfall Model –
- The Waterfall Model is of no use for any maintenance related project and is ideal for long term projects.
- As mentioned in the summary, editing a process once it is in the testing phase is not possible.
- The Waterfall Model works best when the requirements are clear cut and precise.
4. Agile Software Development Methodology
Your project requires you to be flexible and be able to make changes in order to be successful in a turbulent and unforeseen environment. That’s where Agile comes into the picture. It is an umbrella term that encompasses a range of different methods and practices. These methods are based on the values as well as principles that are expressed in the Agile manifesto. Solutions are expected to evolve as cross-functional teams make use of various required practices for the need of the project. That leads to prompt as well as flexible response to change in the process of software development.
Advantages of Agile Software Development Methodology –
- Changes – Agile understands and acknowledges that things will change. However, such changes don’t really disrupt a project. They are in fact turned into a positive not only for the project’s outcome but also for the team involved.
- Creative Options – Agile Software development allows improvements and modifications during the development process and this allows developers to be creative with their design codes.
- Costing and Budgets – The Agile software development process requires a project cost to be estimated at the start of the iteration. This helps the team to understand where to expend resources correctly during the development process.
- High Quality Output – Agile Software Development processes deliver a superior quality product as the processes are divided into smaller parts which in turn make it easier to test and to maintain. This reduces errors and improves quality of the end product.
- Clear Communication – Regular and transparent interaction between the client, the developers and other members of the design process helps to ensure that the project being developed has focus as well as clarity.
Disadvantages of Agile Software Development Methodology –
- There could be issues regarding the clarity of the project if the client is not very sure of how he wants the end result to flow. This in turn will adversely affect everything, from the design process to the budget of the project.
- Agile Software technology focuses more on functional software and does not put any emphasis on paperwork. A lack of basic documentation could be a drawback for the design process especially for references.
- Many traditionalists criticize Agile Software Technology for its non restrictive method of working and claim that it lacks the support of a solid structure.
5. Rapid Application Development (RAD) Methodology
The Rapid Application Development methodology is a way towards faster processing of software. This is achieved by developing functions parallel and then integrating them into a working prototype. This method promises results of a higher quality along with much quicker results which is why it is known as Rapid Application Development. With clients and end users actively taking part in the development process makes this a very user friendly development process. Any risks that development in the process can be dealt with and even changes in the customer’s requirements can be incorporated easily. Developers can easily put checks in place to prevent any major problem in the software creation process and this process also requires and encourages clients and other users for their feedback.
Advantages of Rapid Application Development Methodology –
- All software development processes always benefit from their clients feedback and this helps to maintain and improve standards wherever required.
- The RAD model reduces the risks of errors during the development process as functions are worked on separately and then integrated.
- Regular tests conducted during the RAD process also eliminates chances of expensive errors.
- The client is able to review the development process regularly; this allows changes to be added to the software as and when required.
Disadvantages of Rapid Application Development Methodology –
- The major disadvantage in this process is that this method is not practical for projects on a small budget. The costs involved in automated code generation do not fit into smaller budgets and the cost of modelling is also quite high.
- The RAD process is very dependent on a strong professional team with experienced individuals to understand and identify the client’s requirements and to create them.
- All organisations will not be able to afford a team of designers and skilled professional developers as these come with high costs.
- Only those systems and designs that one can slot into modules can benefit from the Rapid Application Development process and this is not practical for all kinds of software development.
6. Dynamic Systems Development Model
This methodology of software development is part of the Agile Development methodologies where each individual methodology has its own principles and a unique approach. These also have similar features to each other like goal orientation, lightness, flexibility and a focus on continuous development. The DSDM methodology is based on the RAD model and encourages involvement by the user. Among its goals is to develop and to provide software models within the specified budget and within the deadlines. The thought that governs Dynamics Systems Development Methodology is that software development is a constantly changing process as it needs more than one attempt to gain success.
Advantages of Dynamic Systems Development Model –
- The end users are usually more involved in the process of software development in this methodology and therefore are better able to understand the functions of the system.
- With the help of Dynamic Systems Development Methodology the basic functions are easily developed first and more complex or advanced functions are constantly being developed and added to the software.
- Projects using Dynamic Systems Development Methodology are able to limit themselves to the budget on hand and are able to fit the time lines as well.
- Developers and end users both find this methodology easy to use as well as to access.
Disadvantages of Dynamic Systems Development Model –
- The main disadvantage of the Dynamic Systems Development Model is that it is too expensive to implement mainly as both the users as well as the developers have to have the required expertise in order to benefit from the methodology.
- This is not suitable for businesses with a small budget as well as for those developing one time projects.
- As it is a new methodology its use is not common and there are not many experts available who can get the best out of this model.
7. Spiral Model
Developing software is similar to converting a creative concept into a functional and practical system. Unlike a waterfall model a spiral method allows the developer to make changes in the code or in the design even in the testing phase. The Spiral Methodology moves in a loop that is circular, checking the phases of the design until the developer is satisfied. Alterations if any are made and quality checks are performed side by side. With the Spiral model there is the assurance of early detection of risks to the project with steps to reduce them. With the Spiral method of software development a developer will start on a small scale, estimate the risks then find ways to eliminate these risks before deciding whether the project is feasible to continue. Good management is very important to the Spiral Method.
Advantages of Spiral Model –
- Risk factors are reduced as there is it involves extensive Risk Analysis.
- This is an excellent method to use while developing software for important projects and for large projects.
- Additional features and functions can be easily added even as late as the testing phase.
- High Risk projects have benefited from this methodology especially as the requirements of the business can be subject to change and these changes can be made to the software with the Spiral Method.
- The Spiral Method requires the cycles to return to the earlier phases repeatedly thus allowing changes to be factored in.
Disadvantages of Spiral Model –
- This is not always a very cost effective model for software development and has been known to be expensive at times.
- The risk analysis that is done affects the actual success of the model; if the risk analysis is faulty then the entire software project can be negatively affected.
- There is also a risk that the development might keep working in a spiral manner without coming to a conclusion.
- This is not a beneficial method for projects with low risk factors.
8. Extreme Programming Methodology
This is a flexible method that allows changes to be made with changes in requirements. This methodology is based around 4 main activities which are Coding, Testing, Listening and Designing. All these meet together to create software that benefits the client’s requirements. Extreme Programming is best when a software is required to be created within an unstable environment. Developers working with XP Methodology are able to deliver in shorter time frames than with most other methodologies. XP Methodology also encourages feedback from their clients and this feedback is collated by testing the system and from inputs by other developers working on the same project as well as from the client directly.
Advantages of Extreme Programming Methodology –
- XP Methodology’s goal is to lower the costs involved in software development.
- Customer’s involvement is considered important to the success of the XP Method.
- The XP Model puts emphasis on practical plans as well as schedules.
- There is a streamlined process of how developers commit their time to the project.
- The XP model is in line with the best current development methods and therefore developers are able to create software that meets all the standards.
Disadvantages of Extreme Programming Methodology –
- The cost of changing the initial requirements at a later stage with the XP Model can be very high.
- The success of the XP Methodology is very dependent on the people involved in it, the more committed and clearer the vision, the better the end result.
- Using XP requires the various levels of people involved to meet and review often, this does prove to be a drain on the budget.
- Regular Development changes can be difficult for an average developer to handle.
- Providing a realistic quote is another stumbling block as the effort required and the project requirements are difficult to estimate at the beginning of the project.
9. Feature Driven Development (FDD) Methodology
This kind of software development uses the repetitive method also known as an iterative method along with object based technology. This has found favour with larger teams of developers who work on projects that are progressing from working in phases to this iterative approach. An FDD model works by tracking the milestones that are kept for every stage of the progress in the software development with its 5 simple processes and these are Developing the complete model, building the list of features and planning, designing and developing by feature. FDD starts by a review of the scope of the system before domain models are created in great detail for each feature and reviewed again. The selected domain models are then merged into an overall single model.
Advantages of Feature Driven Development Methodology –
- This Methodology is able to move larger projects easily with a large degree of success.
- FDD’s 5 point process (as mentioned above) help to develop software easily with the least time taken.
- FDD follows the standards set by the software development industry and therefore incorporates the best practices of the industry.
Disadvantages of Feature Driven Development Methodology –
- The effort taken for an FDD technology is not feasible for small projects.
- Individual software developers cannot work on such a complex pattern of development.
- The main developer holds the entire framework together and the success of this methodology depends on his skill as a lead designer, mentor and even a coordinator.
- Clients are unable to get the software in writing from the developers thus preventing them from obtaining proof for their software.
10. Joint Application Development (JAD) Methodology
This methodology involves the end user in the development and the design of the software development with the help of interactive workshops. These workshops are also known as JAD sessions. This is thought to have a higher customer satisfaction rate as the client is involved at every stage of the process of development. With its main focus on business solutions over technical ones this is a popular methodology used for clients with growing businesses. This methodology was initially designed for computer based systems but has been successfully used for all kinds of development processes.
Advantages of Joint Application Development Methodology –
- With the help of the JAD sessions users and developers involved in the model get to understand and to learn about various points of view related to the software development.
- Large amounts of information are collated and researched simultaneously which adds to the experience.
- The JAD Methodology within a short time frame is able to produce high quality information related to the software development.
- An organiser plays a very important role in the JAD Methodology by solving all kinds of differences in the software creation process.
- The development process is faster with the JAD Methodology and the chances of errors are fewer.
- The end result with JAD Methodology is of a high quality as focus is always more on the up front process of the development lifecycle which also reduces cost inducing errors.
Disadvantages of Joint Application Development Methodology –
- This process can be time consuming as it requires a fair amount of scheduling and planning between the project development team.
- This is especially true of the JAD sessions as getting the project development team together at the same time is quite a task.
- Expectations from investors for their commitment is very high.
- Very experienced and trained individuals are required to see the project through.
11. Lean Development Methodology
This is a very focused kind of Agile technology as importance is placed on software that is easily changeable. The idea is to create software in as less as 1/3rd of the time as the others, with limited workflow and within a small budget. The object of lean programming is to optimize efficiency and reduce any kind of waste in resources or in time while developing a software. This is achieved by eliminating all that which adds no value to the development process. This could include meetings, documentation etc and emphasizes on imbibing quality in the process.
Advantages of Lean Development Methodology –
- Eliminating unnecessary processes improves the overall efficiency of the software development and helps to reduce errors which in turn speeds up the process.
- The Lean Methodology believes in empowering the team working on the process, this not only creates a better motivated work environment but also helps to hone the decision making ability of the team members.
- The Advantages to completing projects in less time means more time to start on future projects.
- Taking less time to complete projects is also beneficial to meeting deadlines set by the clients.
- The lean method also reduces the need to keep going back to correct errors which wastes time and increases costs.
Disadvantages of Lean Development Methodology –
- The success of the project is very dependent on the teamwork, the discipline between them and how the work flows in between their individual skills.
- Decisions must be prompt and final; this is what makes the Lean Methodology stick to time frames and budgets.
- Flexibility must be supervised as too much of flexibility can be a deterrent to the timely functioning of the team.
- The wrong business analyst will just confuse the documentation pertaining to the process so having the right analyst with ample industry experience is very important.
12. Rational Unified Process Methodology
This Methodology works on the principle of dividing the process flow into 4 distinct parts. These are mainly Analysis and Design, Business Modelling, Deployment, Implementation and Testing. The major difference between Rational Unified Process and the others is that the RUP provides its developers with tools like templates, guidelines and step by step processes and examples for all the stages in the software development process. This process also continuously monitors quality of the software being created and controls changes.
Advantages of Rational Unified Process Methodology –
- There is an emphasis on documentation that is correct.
- These processes are able to fix all the risks that occur when clients add or change their requirements with a process known as Change Request Management.
- Integration is a continuous process throughout the development so a separate timeframe for integration is not required.
- Online tutorials and training is easily available for these processes.
- Components are reused so the development time naturally reduces.
Disadvantages of Rational Unified Process Methodology –
- Untrained team members will be a disadvantage for this process and training them on the job will increase costs and add to the time factor negatively.
- All the stages in this methodology are not always organised and are at times complex.
- At times integration continuously during the process can cause confusions especially during the test phases; this is especially true for larger projects with multiple development streams.
- Reusing components is not always possible especially for those projects that are using the latest technology.
13. Scrum Methodology
Scrum is a framework which makes use of the Agile software development methodology. This framework is flexible and encourages collaborative ways of managing a software project. One of the most recognized benefits of this software development methodology is that it allows you to move quickly and also pivot easily when needed. Faster feedback cycles and the ability to recognize problems early have made Scrum one of the most popular methodologies around.
Advantages of Scrum Methodology –
- Faster Feedback Cycle: There are times when you build exactly as per the requirement. However, that might still not suit the needs of the stakeholders. Scrum ensures that such problems are not recognized late. There is something actionable that can be presented at the end of the first sprint, which ensures that all stakeholders can be kept in the loop.
- Identify Problems Early: Scrum methodology focuses on keeping meetings brief and that lets the teams stay on track. This way, larger problems are identified with ease and can be taken offline without any time being wasted.
- Flexible Prioritization: Scrum offers flexibility in terms of prioritizing customer driven features. With each sprint boundary, it becomes possible for you to more convincingly manage your shippable units of work and make overall progress towards a final product milestone.
Disadvantages of Scrum Methodology –
- The time and cost estimates must be accurate, a careless estimate can adversely affect the project.
- This methodology is ideal for large projects but not so cost effective for smaller projects.
- Coordination between the team members is very important for a smooth flow of the processes involved.
- Experienced and Qualified team members are a must in order to make the Scrum methodology successful.
14. V-Shaped Model
The processes that are a part of this methodology are in a V shaped sequential manner and this process is also known as the Validation and Verification process. This is because there is a corresponding test phase for every stage of the development process. This methodology is ideal for projects that are small to medium sized as the requirements are usually fixed. This also works best when technical resources are in plenty. There are basically 4 steps that are involved in the V Model and these are Unit Testing, Integration Testing, System testing and Acceptance testing. Each requirement and planning phase has a test phase running parallel to it.
Advantages of V-Shaped Model –
- This Methodology is very simple to use and its ease makes it ideal for programmers to use.
- Before coding tests are conducted which include planning and design processes. This way errors are eliminated before the coding even starts.
- Errors are tracked even at the early stages preventing these mistakes from enlarging themselves at later stages in the code.
- The V shaped Method does not allow defects to flow downwards and affect the progress of the software development.
- Ideal for small projects with limited and clear requirements.
Disadvantages of V-Shaped Model –
- This Model is also known as the least flexible model and is also rigid.
- Prototypes or samples are not worked on as the software is created during the initial implementation stage.
- Trying to gauge errors in the beginning of the process could be time consuming.
- An unplanned change during the middle of the development process will make it difficult for the test documents to reflect the same changes.
15. Iterative Model
This model is different from the other as it does not start by specifying requirements of the whole process but instead just a part of the software is specified and implemented and this is reviewed before any further steps are taken. This Model breaks down the software development of a large requirement into smaller more manageable parts. The designing, development and testing is done in a repetitive cycle. As this is repeated each and every cycle of the model gets a new software version produced. There is a working version that is ready quite at the beginning of the process that is tested; evaluated and further additional requirements are then identified.
Advantages of Iterative Model –
- The main advantage of this model is that the process of system development is converted into smaller parts. When the system works correctly all the parts are then coordinated.
- The lessons learnt from the errors that were eliminated from the smaller part can be used to develop the other parts of the process and this goes a long way to save on time and money.
- This Iterative method is also preferred as every permutation and combination need not be considered before starting work on the project.
- Solutions can be easily found as issues crop up by diverting back to the team who can work on solutions while the project development continues forward.
- A working model s available as a sample quite early in the development process and implementing changes is less inexpensive.
Disadvantages of Iterative Model –
- The cyclic design of this model can cause it to go out of its budget as it can get into a repetitive mode.
- Time will need to be spent on closely monitoring deliverables and the time factor in order to live up to its cost saving definition.
- There is no emphasis on maintaining documentation which can cause problems in the long term.
- There are no overlaps in an iterative model which makes it rigid.
Hopefully, this analysis will help you pick the Right methodology for your software development needs.
Get in touch with Us at WeblineIndia (since 1999) to fulfill your offshore web / mobile app development needs using the best suited software development methodology customized for you.